Internal probe of San Diego's lifeguard agency found systemic harassment against women
Published in News & Features
SAN DIEGO — San Diego’s male-dominated lifeguard department has been fostering a systemic culture of harassment against its female lifeguards — one that is reinforced through its policies, practices and the actions of employees and supervisors, according to more than a dozen women interviewed for a city internal investigation revealed through a public records request.
The probe found numerous allegations that men denied women work opportunities and benefits, including training opportunities that lifeguards need for promotion, solely because of their gender.
Female lifeguards reported being sexually harassed both by members of the public and by their own colleagues and supervisors, including cases of unwanted flirting and inappropriate comments, the investigation found.
Multiple female lifeguards reported during the course of the investigation that they have been sexually assaulted by male lifeguards.
When some women reported the harassment, they said supervisors brushed off their complaints, blamed them or retaliated against them.
Other women remained silent about mistreatment because they were afraid to be seen as weak or as causing trouble in a workplace where they were small in number and they felt their capabilities were constantly in question because of their gender.
“I felt like I have to work twice as hard to be half as good. I had to prove myself to the men,” one lifeguard said in an interview for the investigation.
The city’s Equal Employment Investigations Office, which investigates alleged discrimination, harassment and retaliation among employees, conducted the probe into the lifeguard agency, which is part of the San Diego Fire-Rescue Department.
Erin Houston, the office’s investigations manager, said in the 16-page report that the office “found evidence to support systemic and systematic violations of the (Equal Employment Opportunity) Policy in the Lifeguard Division, specifically in how women are treated by their coworkers and supervisors.”
Several portions of the report, including a large portion of its concluding remarks, are redacted.
In response to questions from the Union-Tribune, Fire-Rescue spokesperson Candace Hadley wrote a one-sentence reply: “The City does not comment on personnel matters; however, Chief (Robert) Logan and the San Diego Fire-Rescue Department take all allegations of assault, discrimination and retaliation seriously and claims are thoroughly investigated consistent with City policies and procedures.”
Chief steward of the San Diego lifeguard union, Connor Robbins, said in a statement that the union takes these matters seriously.
“These investigations serve an important purpose in promoting a fair, respectful, and equitable workplace where concerns can be raised and addressed through an established process,” Robbins said.
“While we cannot comment on specific allegations, individuals, or ongoing investigations, we remain committed to advocating for our members and ensuring they are afforded due process and their rights are protected throughout,” he added.
A series of probes
San Diego Lifeguard Services is a round-the-clock rescue agency charged with keeping people safe over 24 miles of coastline from Point Loma to Torrey Pines.
The department has about 320 lifeguards, of which more than a third are full-time employees, according to the lifeguard union.
Fire-Rescue would not say how many lifeguards are men and how many are women.
The August investigation findings paint a wider backdrop for the recent series of news events that has shaken Lifeguard Services, beginning with the sudden discharge of its chief, James Gartland, on Oct. 5.
City officials still have not said publicly why they discharged Gartland, who had served as chief since 2018 and worked in the department for more than three decades.
But internal documents produced in response to a record request by the Union-Tribune show the Equal Employment Investigations Office had issued several reports detailing substantiated misconduct against women in the months leading up to Gartland’s discharge.
The investigation report, which found overall, systemic violations of the city’s equal employment opportunity policy, was sent to Fire-Rescue leadership on Aug. 12, almost two months prior to Gartland’s discharge.
On Sept. 16, three weeks before Gartland’s discharge, Fire-Rescue leaders were notified of probes that found violations of the city’s equal employment opportunity policy in three separate cases of alleged sexual harassment against female lifeguards.
One of those investigations made headlines last month. That probe found Gartland and two lifeguard sergeants prevented what should have been a formal investigation into a female lifeguard’s claims of sexual harassment by pressuring her to resign, despite city policy that requires supervisors to immediately report complaints of harassment or discrimination to the Equal Employment Investigations Office.
In addition to those three cases, two additional investigations — one completed in May of this year and one completed in June 2023 — into alleged harassment and discrimination also found violations of the city’s equal employment opportunity policy.
Among those probes’ findings:
—Investigators concluded “it is more likely than not” that in October 2025, a male lifeguard raped a female lifeguard he was dating. She asked him to stop contacting her. Despite this, he messaged and called her repeatedly and left her gifts over the course of months, the investigation found. She quit her lifeguard job because of him and the harassment, investigators said.
—A female lifeguard alleged a male lifeguard broke into her room and forced himself on her during a work-related trip in Baja California in April 2016, attempting to kiss her. She said she fought him off then ran into another room — but he found her and tried to force himself on her again. The male lifeguard denied this, but investigators concluded it is “more likely than not” that she was telling the truth because his account conflicted with witnesses’ statements.
—A male lifeguard asked a subordinate female lifeguard in May 2026 if she would pose with a surfboard for his painting, shortly after asking another male lifeguard whether she had a boyfriend, the investigation found. She said she told him she’d consider it because he controlled whether she could get training opportunities needed to advance in her career, according to the report. The painting session never happened.
—A male lifeguard sergeant denied a female lifeguard an opportunity to drive to an out-of-town training because of her gender around June 2022, investigators concluded. He said he presumed they would have to book an additional lodging room for her and presumed they wouldn’t be able to afford it. He gave the opportunity to two lifeguards who had less seniority than her.
Officials with San Diego Fire-Rescue would not say whether any of the men in these cases have been disciplined or are still working for the department.
City officials appointed Gartland’s replacement just four days after he was removed. They installed a man with a legal background: Deputy City Attorney Daniel Orloff, who has about five years of full-time lifeguarding experience.
A month later, Lifeguard Services was dealt one more complaint of discrimination.
The department’s second-highest-ranking lifeguard, Marine Safety Capt. Maureen Hodges, sued San Diego on Nov. 9 alleging gender discrimination because she was not given the chance to apply for the chief job, despite being highest-ranked after the chief and having more years of lifeguarding leadership than Orloff.
Hodges was the first female sergeant and is the first and only female captain in the 108-year history of the department.
San Diego’s lifeguard department has over the years faced complaints of discrimination and harassment against women.
Hodges’ attorney, Mike Conger, represented six female lifeguards in the 2000s and 2010s alleging gender discrimination or sexual harassment.
Several of those women said they were systematically prevented — sometimes for years — from getting promoted from part-time to full-time lifeguard because of department practices, such as performance reviews and candidate interview preparation, that made it easier for men and harder for women to get promoted.
Back then, fewer than 10 of the city’s approximately 100 full-time lifeguards were women.
All of Conger’s cases settled except for one, Alison Terry’s case, which went to trial. She won.
“The Hodges case is really the same song, different verse,” Conger said in an interview. “The Lifeguard Service was, and still is, of men, by men and for men.”
‘A need to prove yourself more’
The Equal Employment Investigations Office began investigating how the lifeguard department treats women because of one lifeguard’s Instagram post in April 2026. That lifeguard wrote that the department’s culture fosters “pervasive” sexual harassment against women.
“To be a woman in this space is to place your own actions under a microscope, constantly examining yourself for any wrong move,” she wrote. “There have been countless instances where I smiled or nodded or shrugged things off silently because I did not want to make waves.”
The office interviewed or received written statements from 18 current and former female lifeguards as part of its investigation. Investigators said they did not identify any of those witnesses in the report because the women had “tremendous fear” of retaliation and cited cases in which women had been punished for reporting sexual harassment.
Together, the interviews described a workplace where women are far outnumbered by men, have to meet higher standards than men, have to work harder or curry favor to be accepted and feel forced to compete with other women.
“When you are the only women, you feel othered, perceived more than your male coworkers. There is a need to prove yourself more and show that you are more physically capable, to outperform everyone in order to get the basic respect from men,” one lifeguard told investigators.
Most of the women interviewed by the office said they have been ignored and excluded by male colleagues and supervisors. They said men avoid talking to them, making eye contact with them or greeting them, but will physically embrace other men.
One lifeguard said she went weeks without a male coworker speaking to her. “It seems like it isn’t a big deal, but it eats away at you,” she said.
Ten women said men in the department have told them personally that the only reason they were hired or promoted was because they are women.
Several women said the disparate treatment was also reinforced by female employees and supervisors.
One lifeguard said that some women were supportive, but there “was this attitude that we dealt with it to get where we are, so you can deal with it too. It’s like men see us as weaker and sensitive, so don’t reinforce that.”
Sexual harassment
Most of the women said they are frequently sexually harassed by members of the public, but their supervisors do not step up to defend or protect them. They have been catcalled and told sexual comments about their bodies.
Female lifeguards said they have also been harassed by their own male colleagues and supervisors.
Several said male coworkers have made derogatory comments about their bodies, such as how their weight makes them look in a swimsuit, the investigation report said.
One lifeguard said her work mentor, who was male and older, asked if she would cheat on her boyfriend with him, the report said. He said he thought she was flirting with him because she went on swims and truck patrols with him. “I told him it was my job to be in shape and patrol the beach,” she said.
Another lifeguard reported that a male lifeguard asked to walk her to her car, to which she said no repeatedly, then he told her he wanted to do something sexual to her.
Multiple female lifeguards reported they were sexually assaulted or harassed by male lifeguards at employee bar hangouts after work. One lifeguard said she was groped by a male coworker at such a bar hangout and saw other women being groped, investigators said.
Multiple female lifeguards indicated that when they reported misconduct to male colleagues or supervisors, their complaints were dismissed and, in some cases, they were blamed or punished instead, according to the report.
One lifeguard said she filed a complaint about a male lifeguard hitting on her while she was wearing a work bikini. Her supervisor didn’t address the harassment and instead said to her, “Do you want to start wearing a one-piece from now on?,” the report said.
Under state law, employers with at least five workers must have all their employees complete sexual harassment prevention training at least once every two years.
But female lifeguards told city investigators that many lifeguards don’t actually complete the training.
The city’s harassment prevention training is computer-based, but many lifeguard stations don’t have a computer. The training takes two consecutive hours to complete, and many lifeguards will get called away on a rescue during the training, so they’ll ask someone else to keep pushing the training buttons after they head out, lifeguards said.
Women told investigators they’ve seen male colleagues treat the training as a joke. They said it’s common for men to print out their completed training certificates and put them on refrigerators in employee common areas. One lifeguard said it’s interpreted as a joke that they are “100% certified to sexually harass,” according to the report.
Limited opportunities
Female lifeguards also reported that their work opportunities were curtailed solely because of their gender.
Women’s location and scheduling assignments are based on their gender, the report said. For example, lifeguards said, leadership spreads women out across divisions to avoid having them working together at one lifeguard station.
“It was like … they didn’t trust the women to hold down that station,” one lifeguard said.
Lifeguards have to accumulate training while on the job to move up the ranks in Lifeguard Services. But according to department policy, training opportunities are not offered on a regular or guaranteed basis. Instead, they are offered at the discretion of officers in charge of training “whenever practical.” That means training officers are able to dole out training based on who they like, women said.
Women said they have been denied training opportunities after asking multiple times and have been left out of training opportunities given to men. One lifeguard said it took years of her asking to get training, while she watched male coworkers get training in a fraction of the time. Most of the women interviewed alleged it’s very hard to get training unless you’re a man, an attractive woman or are dating a senior employee.
“There were men who had been with the service for fewer years who got more opportunities than me. It’s supposed to be merit-based training, and I’d have to tell myself maybe I wasn’t performing as well as they are, but it was definitely something I thought about, that they were getting training faster than me because I’m a lady,” one lifeguard told investigators.
One female lifeguard alleged gender bias was at play in lifeguard testing. She claimed a male lifeguard who was in charge of administering a lifeguard skills test was giving women harder questions and scores on the test than he did for men.
Investigators could not confirm whether the employee did this because the male lifeguard admitted he does not use written or standardized questions for the test and he does not document test scores. He told investigators he comes up with test questions “in the moment” and decides himself whether a lifeguard passes or fails. He could provide investigators with no documentation as to what questions he asked the female lifeguard or why she failed the test.
City investigators flagged this to Fire-Rescue and said they need to review the lifeguard department’s testing to ensure it is fair and unbiased.
Investigators also said Fire-Rescue should reevaluate how sexual harassment prevention training is administered in the department.
Fire-Rescue would not say whether it is reevaluating lifeguard testing practices or administration of harassment prevention training.
Houston of the employment investigations office sent the report to leaders of Fire-Rescue, who, according to city rules, are the ones responsible for resolving the violations and taking steps to prevent future ones. The report was also sent to the city’s Human Resources and Personnel departments and the City Attorney’s Office.
_____
©2026 The San Diego Union-Tribune. Visit sandiegouniontribune.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.







Comments