Colorado Bureau of Investigation evidence technician under investigation amid allegations she staged photos
Published in News & Features
DENVER — A longtime evidence technician at the Colorado Bureau of Investigation is under criminal investigation amid allegations that she staged evidence photos, according to a letter the CBI sent to district attorneys in October.
Cathy Moulds, a toxicology evidence technician, was placed on administrative leave on Sept. 23 amid allegations that she faked some evidence photos, according to the Oct. 9 letter, which was obtained by The Denver Post Thursday.
Moulds was responsible for receiving toxicology evidence at CBI’s Denver Regional Laboratory, logging it into CBI’s internal system, photographing it and then moving the evidence along in the intake process, according to the letter, which was signed by CBI’s Deputy Director of Forensic Services Lance Allen.
“The issue under investigation is whether, in some cases, Moulds reconstructed the packaging and seal to make later photos taken after analysis appear to be original intake photos, instead of documenting a correction,” the letter reads.
Moulds, who started at CBI in 2007, declined to comment Friday. Rob Low, a spokesman for CBI, said in a statement Friday that the agency has “no evidence of any test samples or results being compromised,” and said Moulds “performs no scientific work.” Leadership at CBI became aware of “potential internal documentation policy violations,” on Sept. 22 and placed Moulds on leave the next day, he said.
The Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office is conducting a criminal investigation, and that probe that is ongoing, said Brionna Boatright, a spokeswoman for the First Judicial District Attorney’s Office, where the Arvada lab is located. Moulds was the primary toxicology evidence technician and handled most of the toxicology evidence submitted to the regional lab over the past decade, according to the notification letter.
Moulds did not test blood samples herself, according to the letter. That work is handled by toxicologists, who break the seal on the blood tubes, sample the blood and perform chemical testing.
“At this time, there is no evidence that she opened or altered a test tube,” CBI’s letter read. “She had no responsibility for testing the blood, and there is no evidence Moulds’ conduct affected the chemical analysis.”
It was not immediately clear how many cases could be affected by Moulds’ actions. CBI by Oct. 9 had notified district attorneys in four cases where Moulds was under subpoena to testify and 10 cases that involved “alleged wrongful action under the (Forensic Sciences Integrity Act),” according to the letter. The letter noted that investigators have not yet established the “full scope” or reached conclusions in the probe.
Boatright said her office has shared CBI’s Oct. 9 letter with defense attorneys in all six of its open cases that involve Moulds.
Moulds was placed on administrative leave just two weeks after former CBI scientist Yvonne ‘Missy’ Woods was sentenced to 10 years in prison in a years-long DNA testing scandal within CBI that shook confidence in the state’s criminal justice system. The two women worked at the same Arvada crime laboratory.
Woods mishandled more than 1,000 cases in her 29-year career as a DNA analyst at CBI. She deleted, omitted and manipulated data to speed up the DNA testing process and boost her productivity, creating unreliable results in hundreds of criminal cases.
Iris Eytan, founder of the nonprofit Protect Ethical Prosecutors, said Friday that the allegations against Moulds are “extremely concerning,” particularly in light of the Woods scandal.
“You have evidence of a pattern of misconduct in a Colorado lab that is certified,” she said, referring to both Woods and Moulds. “It is extremely concerning. …This should raise eyebrows that it is not a one-off.”
Lawmakers passed the Forensic Sciences Integrity Act in response to the Woods scandal — CBI in Woods’ case failed to act despite multiple warnings over several years about Woods’ behavior. The new law was intended to force CBI to be more transparent and proactive about potential wrongdoing, giving prompt notifications to prosecutors, defendants and potential victims.
CBI made no public announcements about the investigation into Moulds when she was placed on leave or when the agency notified prosecutors about the potential misconduct. The investigation into her is the sixth to occur under the Forensic Sciences Integrity Act, Low said. The law took effect in June 2025 but lawmakers made it retroactive through 2014, requiring a review of prior incidents. The six investigations under the act includes the probe into Woods, Low said.
The Colorado District Attorney’s Council, which supports the state’s prosecutors, urged prosecutors not to tie Moulds to Woods in an undated six-page document titled, “Moulds FSIA Investigation Communications Plan,” obtained by The Post Thursday.
The unsigned document urged district attorneys to focus on process in their public comments, and emphasized that CBI placed Moulds on leave “within 24 hours hours of learning of the alleged behavior, opened a FSIA investigation, referred it for criminal review, and notified every DA in writing in about two weeks.”
Prosecutors should avoid “speculating about whether or not evidence coming from CBI Labs is trustworthy or reliable,” the document advised.
_____
©2026 MediaNews Group, Inc. Visit at denverpost.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.







Comments